Nichiha Vintage Wood – Cedar Siding is one of the most beloved and enduring choices for home exteriors. Revered for its natural beauty, exceptional durability, and aromatic fragrance, cedar provides a level of warmth and visual texture that is difficult to match with synthetic materials. Beyond aesthetics, its natural resistance to decay and insects makes it a sustainable and long-lasting investment. However, choosing cedar is only the first step. The material is sold in several distinct grades, and understanding the differences between them—particularly in terms of appearance, longevity, and cost—is crucial for ensuring your investment meets your aesthetic goals and budget requirements. Selecting the wrong grade can lead to unexpected maintenance, a shorter lifespan, or a final look that falls short of your vision.
The grading system for cedar, primarily Western Red Cedar or Alaskan Yellow Cedar, is established by industry bodies and is based on criteria such as the presence of knots, the flatness of the grain, and the potential for defects. These grades fall broadly into two categories: clear cedar and knotty cedar. While both are 100% natural cedar, they offer wildly different visual profiles and, consequently, different price points and maintenance expectations.
Exploring Knotty Grades: Rustic Charm and Value
Knotty cedar grades are sourced from the younger, faster-growing parts of the tree and are celebrated for their rustic, character-rich appearance. These grades contain knots, which can vary in size and frequency. Knotty cedar is typically much more affordable than the clear grades and offers excellent value for money.
The top tier of knotty cedar is often called Custom Knotty or Select Knotty. This grade features knots that are sound and tight—meaning they are firmly attached to the wood and are unlikely to fall out over time. The appearance is appealingly rustic without being structurally flawed. This is an excellent choice for homes seeking a warm, cabin-like, or traditional aesthetic, and it is the most popular choice for general residential siding. It accepts stains well, allowing the knots to show through and deepen the wood’s natural character.
The next grade down might be labeled Quality Knotty or Standard and Better. This grade permits larger knots, some blemishes, and may include knots that are “tight but black.” While still structurally sound, this wood has a more pronounced, rugged appearance and requires slightly more careful cutting during installation to work around unavoidable defects. It is often the preferred choice for projects where budget is a primary concern, or where the style calls for a more distressed or rugged look.
Finish and Maintenance: Impact on Longevity
Regardless of the grade you choose, the lifespan of your cedar siding is highly dependent on the finish and subsequent maintenance. The finish protects the wood from UV radiation and moisture, which are the main culprits behind degradation.
- Semi-Transparent Stains: These finishes allow the natural color and grain of the cedar (including the knots) to show through. They are often preferred for knotty grades to enhance the rustic look. Stains must be reapplied more frequently—typically every 3 to 5 years—as they wear away faster than solid paint.
- Solid Stains or Paints: These provide the highest level of UV and moisture protection, and they are essential for preserving the pristine look of clear cedar. While paint requires maintenance, a high-quality acrylic paint applied correctly can last 10 to 15 years before needing a refresh.
It is crucial to understand that knotty cedar, because of the knots, has slightly different maintenance demands. Knots contain high levels of resin, which can cause bleeding or discoloration through paint over time, requiring a high-quality primer before painting. Clear grades are generally easier to paint smoothly.
Conclusion: Aligning Grade with Vision
Choosing the right grade of cedar siding is a decision that must align the home’s architectural style, the desired aesthetic, and the project budget. The choice is a deliberate one: do you seek the refined, flawless consistency of clear cedar, or the rich, authentic character of knotty cedar? Both grades offer the natural resistance and durability that make cedar a superior siding material. By understanding the core differences in grain, knot presence, maintenance needs, and cost, homeowners can make an informed investment that ensures their cedar exterior remains beautiful, robust, and a source of pride for many decades to come.
About the Author
